question-circle Reading & Writing

16 years 3 months ago #94503 by LoriF
Replied by LoriF on topic Re: Reading & Writing
I was able to read very well by the time I got to grade 1 - SubA in my days - mainly because my mom was a teacher. Whilst the teacher thought I was little wunderchild and even asked her husband, who taught grade 7, to allow me to "demonstrate my skills" to his class, she did not provide alternative stimulation. So I sat there bored out of my skull as she was trying to teach the other kids to read. This persisted throughout primary school and I once got a massive trashing because I brought my own books to school and read them whilst the other kids were painfully trying to navigate the school issued text books that I had read cover to cover on the first day on the new school year. In the end I just lost interest and did not actually do all that well at school - certainly not living up to my potential.
So, whilst it is great that she learns to read early, make sure that whatever school she goes to will cater for her abilities.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 years 3 months ago #94195 by Claudia_B
Replied by Claudia_B on topic Re: Reading & Writing
They teach reainf and letter recognition concurrently now, so yes they intitially read by recognition, not by spelling out the word, but at the same time they are being taught writing and phonics where they are taught to write and sound letters. A child should know the alphabet song before grade 1 - even if they cant draw or recognise the letters.

This is actually not that strange. Most young children will recognise macdonalds by the big M. They cant read, yet will know it as macdonalds. The same with stop signs etc... When I was in Russia (where they use the cyrillic alphabet) it was macdonalds, citibank and common "brands" that helped me to identify the sounds that the different shaped letters made and thus read road signs etc...

As for teaching reading and writing, if your child is ready and willing ot learn then go for it, but dont force the issue. It may put her a step above the other kids in grade 1, but long term it wont make any difference. Kids will catch up quickly!

Mom to one little boy born 21 April 2010
physiomommy.blogspot.com

File Attachment:


File Attachment:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 years 3 months ago #94077 by Claire A
Replied by Claire A on topic Re: Reading & Writing
Personally, I believe in allowing children to be children for as long as possible. I would not put added pressure on a child by making them do classes when they will be learning soon anyway.
At 4, it is more important to learn thru playing than thru formal lesons - but that is how I feel.

And re the grade 1 boy who cannot spell - give him time, I am almost 40 and I STILL can't spell either :) :blush:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 years 3 months ago #94060 by Amandalynn-3j*Lorelai-3m
Im not doing it myself as i don't have the patience for it. i have a teacher doing it.



Lorelai: born 27 Jan 2010 Amandalynn: born 28 Jun 2006

These are my princesses!!!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 years 3 months ago #93934 by Barbara
Replied by Barbara on topic Re: Reading & Writing
They teach reading differently now than when we were kids. they do teach them first to recognize words before spelling them - it is not only approached like that in SA and it has been recognized as the preferable way to approach reading for years now.

If you are homeschooling I dont think there is an issue how you teach her but if you intend her to go to school then teaching her one way which is different to how she will be taught to read in school can cause her alot of problems and confusion - schools strongly recommend against teaching a child to read before they go to school because of this specifically.
Maybe buy a book on learning to read before approaching teaching her so that you are doing it in the same way as she will be expected to do so later?

My son is currently in grade R and they are being taught the basics of the alphabet (reciting the alphabet and knowing/recognising it on sight are 2 different things). He cannot read though he can recognise certain words (eg. his and his sisters names). So he also does not know the alphabet though he does know the song (I dont think he actually even connects the song to what he is learning).

I am as yet in no rush for him to read and he has not asked yet to learn - maybe if it came from his side I would help him but at this stage I am happy to let him go through at the pace of the normal schooling process.

Mom to Rafe (5) & Kara (3)
WAHM & Doula (South Coast based)
Earth Babies Blog

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 years 3 months ago #93916 by Amandalynn-3j*Lorelai-3m
Hey

ek het dieselfde gedink, maar n vriendin van my wat n arbeid terapeut is se dat Amandalynn fine sal wees op daai ouderdom, agv haar geaardheid. ek stress net so bietjie. sy is n rustige kind en sal haarself entertain.



Lorelai: born 27 Jan 2010 Amandalynn: born 28 Jun 2006

These are my princesses!!!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 years 3 months ago #93772 by *Joli*
Replied by *Joli* on topic Re: Reading & Writing
Schools got very specific ways they teach the kids to read, write and spell. My daughter is also in Grade 1 and couldn't read when she started. She can now read her home work books (still struggling a bit). She gets 2 books a day to read. They've got a thing called THRASS which they follow to teach the kids.

They first learn to read before the learn to spell as well. It's strange that he does not know the alphabet. Megan is 2 1/2 and knows the whole alphabet song (not that she really knows what it means :P ).

With regards to teaching your daughter. I think it's OK to teach her the basics, but don't you think she will be bored in class when everyone learns how to read and write and she can already do it?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Powered by Kunena Forum
Don't have an account yet? Register Now!

Sign in to your account