file Thumbs up/Thumbs down buttons?

15 years 3 months ago - 15 years 3 months ago #201143 by Juno
I'm beginning to think on a site like Moomie we should only have the thank you or even better like button.
The following user(s) said Thank You: julz

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 3 months ago #201120 by gloeiwurmpie
I like the "thank you button". A user can express her gratitude towards specific advice given.

I don't like the karma that much. It feels like a high school popularity contest.
I don't like the idea that users can give negative karma towards other users. This will only cause tension between users, trying to figure out who has taken away their karma.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Joybaby

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 3 months ago #201100 by Joybaby
Good post Juno. I dont think the Karma button is getting its intended purpose out.

I dont like the 'unlike' feature either, in my mind either I like it and I click on + or I just leave it. Have not thought about clicking the '-' button on anyones post.

Altho it is somewhat depressing some days that apparently no one likes my posts since my Karma rating is a big fat zero! And I do get jealous of the coolness that is R.M with her 37 karma rating :D But thats the insecurity in me speaking. I know I'm not nearly as cool as RM anyways you have an awesome way with words even if I dont always agree with the opinion.

First angel resting 25/06/2009 stayed with us a short 7 weeks but we still miss you.

File Attachment:
File Attachment:


File Attachment:
File Attachment:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 3 months ago - 15 years 3 months ago #201038 by Juno
(If this appears out of context it was in response to another posting that has subsequently been withdrawn).

My point exactly. Ratings should be about what is said not who you are.

Although I do agree that there are those who use anonymity for malicious intent it certainly does have its place.

Just because I happen to give a specific post a thumbs down does not mean to imply that I have an issue with the person. If I am going to get confronted for every thumbs down I give I'm eventually going to stop all together. In my mind that is impinging on freedom of speech as I would not feel "safe" expressing myself freely and without consequence.

Opinions tend to differ vastly on this particular subject..always a hot one.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 3 months ago - 15 years 3 months ago #200971 by Reluc.t.ant M.o.m
---- I am going to step out of this discussion.

What keeps me (partially) sane ...
reluctantmom.wordpress.com/

What makes me smile ...
celestebarlow.wordpress.com/

What no one says out loud ...
dirtylittlesecretsmotherskeep.wordpress.com/

Location: CY country
Off spring: 3 (ages range from 2 - 9 years old)

Struggling to juggle life, kids, work, my bottle of wine, without having a total humour failure.

I have a letter from my pdoc to say I am insane, so tread lightly with me, some days I can be a total bitch. I'm lying. Most days I am a total bitch.

I abhor smiley face icons. Just saying.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 3 months ago #200964 by Bronz

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 3 months ago - 15 years 3 months ago #200962 by Juno
When this was requested I thought it was going to be like News24 where you give a thumbs up or down for individual articles or in Moomies case, thread postings.

It's really not cool seeing a negative karma next to a specific individual's names nor I think is it particularly fair.

Can't we do it based on the content of a posting rather than a specific individual's name?

I for one will be sure to reverse any negative karmas I see.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Powered by Kunena Forum
Don't have an account yet? Register Now!

Sign in to your account