I've used both and it really depends on the child and what you are comfortable with. Early potty training babies I've used a potty because its smaller and more comfy for their little bums, bigger kids the toilet with a step stool. Right now I'm using a potty. Purely because J has just turned 2 and there are 2 other babies in the house so if I;m busy with them he can easily go by himself (which he does

) I've shown him how to empty the potty into the toilet and rinse it and put it back so very little input from me