file Private versus Public school - the hateful debate

15 years 9 months ago #153093 by Reluc.t.ant M.o.m
Julz - I share your earlier thoughts on Bishops - do not get me wrong I think it is a brilliant school, and offers the best a school can.

I put Connor on a waiting list when he was in Grade 1 for Bishops, and I paid the application/registration fee.

But, and this is where I agree with you Julz, that I do not think I am Bishops people.

I think I would probably feel more comfortable with Rondebosch Boys, instead of Bishops.

The fees are enough to make me throw up in my mouth a bit. If I had one child I may consider it, but I have 3, which would mean Connor can go there and Georgia and Isabelle would need to go to a farm school in the Karoo as that is all I could afford.

But even if we could afford it, and odds are then we will be okay, it is the same reason I dislike Cavendish, it is so pretentious and ponsy. Even if I drove a Jaguar, I would still be me driving a jag, I could not be ponsy if my life dependent on it.

I love the idea of Bishops. I love the idea of the old boys network, and no one works it like Bishops - those connections go on forever.

But odds are when Connor gets to Grade 6 and starts testing for high schools to get in, I will probably not look at Bishops. (I might, I might be a bit more ponsy than I am by then, and stop using the word fek!)

What keeps me (partially) sane ...
reluctantmom.wordpress.com/

What makes me smile ...
celestebarlow.wordpress.com/

What no one says out loud ...
dirtylittlesecretsmotherskeep.wordpress.com/

Location: CY country
Off spring: 3 (ages range from 2 - 9 years old)

Struggling to juggle life, kids, work, my bottle of wine, without having a total humour failure.

I have a letter from my pdoc to say I am insane, so tread lightly with me, some days I can be a total bitch. I'm lying. Most days I am a total bitch.

I abhor smiley face icons. Just saying.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago - 15 years 9 months ago #153088 by julz
Bishops current fees are 70640 per annum. At least it prepares you for vasity costs!!

This exlcude the no refundable enrollment fee charged for the first applicant of a family of R17000.00

Mom of Dylan and Partner to Joerg. We live in the Beautiful Pringle Bay which is along the Whale coast, Cape.


File Attachment:
File Attachment:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #153082 by zakira
Hi Milou

I was never at a private school myself, but we've gone private for my daughter as my husband was an ex Bishops pupil and my sil was an ex St Cyrpians pupil. Although we muslim , we've sent her to Springfield Convent and are extremely happy with there religious back group, teacher student ratio etc. Ive also had nieces and nephews who have attended Bishops and Hershel who always say that if they had a choice , they'd send their children to the same schools they were at. I think if i had a son i would also have chosen Bishops , i think they've got the all round excellence in academics, sport and cultural aspects. They also offer extra murals which many public schools.

Oh forgot to mention we in Cape Town.

Wishing you best of luck with your decision

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152956 by milou
Heya Claudia - I'm in Maritzburg which is known for it's fabulous private schools! The thing about PMB though is that it has grown very big very fast and as a result there is actually a lack of state schools! A positive and negative aspect of this is that all the State schools have a very mixed demographic - very affluent and very poor in the same class and totally multi-cultural. I am from Durban originally and in the Glen-ashley / Durban North area (where I was staying) there were quite a few state schools (more so than private) and I think that maybe Maritzburg is just under-supplied with schools and over-supplied with children.

St. Henry's has a good reputation - I understand they take girls now too which is nice.

This issue is just one of the many things they DON'T tell you about when you're pregnant! :lol:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152925 by Claudia_B
@ Milou - where in Durbs are you??

I'm going private - for no reason other than our governments penchant for changing curriculum at a whim. I want stability:)
That said I think you need to look at the child, your own circumstances and the schools in your feeder area...

The school my sister teachers at has a student teacher ratio of 15-20:1 plus they have TA's and an OT on site. They have a heated swimming pool and loads of ground for sports. It seems like a very nice school and parents in the area seem to like it. Being a government school they are forced to take kids in that are within their feeder area which means that they do have some kids from difficult backgrounds. My sister had the dubious honour of being the teacher for the not streamed Gr1's (children with no previous formal schooling). She is spending the whole 1st term of school readiness because most of her kids have poor english skills and have never held a pencil. I would hazard a guess that most private schools do not have this problem......

Private schools can give children an inferiority complex if they can not be like the jones's. They often offer fewer subject choices and I know some of the bigger more prestigeous boys schools can be problematic for more sensitive arty type boys (think poor gekko in spud)

My feeling is, if you can find a government school that you are happy with, and if going private is going to mean that you wont be able to do anything else with your kids, its probably better to go government.

I'm hoping to send James to MArist brothers St Henrys, but only because I like the catholic ethos its one of the cheaper private schools (so less exclusive) and I'm not going to have to sell organ parts to afford it.

Mom to one little boy born 21 April 2010
physiomommy.blogspot.com

File Attachment:


File Attachment:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152778 by Jems
We have a few Waldorf schools here but they are just as pricy as private!

Lucky for me I have my mom and MIL who look after the kids while I work and they are not at school. DH also works at home quite a bit.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152773 by Reluc.t.ant M.o.m
Milou, aftercare is also a factor that you would need to look at.

The schools my children are in at the moment - are both Model C/government schools and both offer holiday programmes and after care.

School finishes around 1pm, I fetch kids around 3:30pm, sometimes later.

The schools my kids are in offer a/care, and my daughters does a cooked lunch, etc. My son's offers homework assistance, so someone sits with him and does his homework with him, so that is ticked off my list.

I pay a little extra and then it means that I do not have to pay for the holiday programmes, and my kids can attend in the holiday periods.

There is always a 2 - 3 week gap in December/January where schools are closed, and so too is holiday programme and they are then at home.

When you are calculating school costs it is good to find out fees, and find out what time school ends, and then ask if after care is available and the additional cost.

This usually adds about 60% to the cost of monthly school fees.

What keeps me (partially) sane ...
reluctantmom.wordpress.com/

What makes me smile ...
celestebarlow.wordpress.com/

What no one says out loud ...
dirtylittlesecretsmotherskeep.wordpress.com/

Location: CY country
Off spring: 3 (ages range from 2 - 9 years old)

Struggling to juggle life, kids, work, my bottle of wine, without having a total humour failure.

I have a letter from my pdoc to say I am insane, so tread lightly with me, some days I can be a total bitch. I'm lying. Most days I am a total bitch.

I abhor smiley face icons. Just saying.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Powered by Kunena Forum
Don't have an account yet? Register Now!

Sign in to your account