file Private versus Public school - the hateful debate

15 years 9 months ago #152772 by Elamsmom
Hi ladies

Don't have much time to chat as will be going into a marathon meeting just now :(

Anyway, here's my 2cents worth. My older sisters all went to this incredibly expensive private school in Pietermaritzburg and when it came time for me to go to boarding school my parents decided that they hadn't seen any DRASTIC rewards/returns on the money they'd spent on private education so my younger bro. & I were sent to a govt school in Port Elizabeth (much to my dissapointment and resentment!!!) Anyway, it turned out to be an AMAZING government (semi-private) school at a fraction on the price. It was one of these -founded in 1874 with deeply entrenched cultrural and behavioural value systems (just to give a sneak preview- we use to have to STAND ASIDE at doorways if anyone more senior that u was coming -even if they were A MILE away!!!)

Anyway, I excelled at this school and got academic and sport acollades (I was one of those annoying kids with an honors blazer that had no more space for scrolls and badges :laugh: -not sure what happened after high school :laugh: ) Point is, 1)there are still very good public/govt schools and 2) it largely depends on the child's attitude/support from parents/disposition/self-discipline etc.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago - 15 years 9 months ago #152771 by milou
So glad I posted! I was dead keen on Waldorf schooling and Montessori as well - My daughter is also artsy and I think I would have loved Waldorf (the TOTAL geek that I am) but here in KZN there is only one Waldorf school and it's quite a way from where I am so it's not an option! I'm so impressed that schools in the Cape offer holiday care - clearly I'm in the wrong province!

+++1 to the financial aspect Julz raised. I don't want the daughter to grow up feeling like she's less affluent than her peers or with some ghastly sense of entitlement. I know of two girls who were taken out of the same private school here and transferred to government schools based on a dip in their parent's financial situations - both girls are thriving now in the government school environment - enjoying the co-ed aspect and the face that they don't feel poor anymore!

The government school (jolly-hockey-place) is an ex-model C and it's close and affordable but no arts program beyond recorder and choir for Grade 3 upwards. A big focus on sport (ugghh) and no holiday care! Sucks!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152766 by julz
I hope to be in a position by then to be able to have him home with me. I work from home. His daymom does offer an aftercare service which I would use if I had to work away from home.

Mom of Dylan and Partner to Joerg. We live in the Beautiful Pringle Bay which is along the Whale coast, Cape.


File Attachment:
File Attachment:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152758 by Jems
This question is plaguing me too milou!

I am currently looking for a primary school for Jade. It is hard. She is such a free spirited, arty, dancy type and I don't want her individuality to be lost in a class of 30! Yet at the same time she does need structure and I want her to have choices when she is older. I want her to be able to choose whether she wants to study drama or be a lawyer and have the schooling to back it all up!! Hard hard hard.

Julz is right about the financial aspect too.

What are you thoughts on Waldorf Schooling ladies? Keen to try it out? I think they have a good idea there... It fits nicely with me for some reason.

DH is very main stream so not very happy. He was a jock at school and I was a nerd apparently, we went to the same school yet had such different experiences!!!!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152756 by MissesMom
I'm very pro private if you can afford - I like the school we have Em in because they are service providers. I like the fact if I am not happy about something I actually have the power to do something about it.

But there are wonderful public schools as well. Em's school is 5km away from us, so also a nice choice there, but Durbanville is full of wonderful private and public model C schools.

Her school also does offer a holiday club where you can send your children during the holidays, which is stunning for me. They have pre-care in the mornings - so drop off is from 6:30 - and then also after-care with meals provided till 6pm as well.

All in all I am very happy with her school, and am more than happy to pay the fee's involved.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152750 by milou
And another thing - working parents - what do you do with the offspring during holidays? Neither government nor private schools seem to offer holiday care.. I'm okay now that she's in a pre-school that does - but what happens next year? :blink:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 years 9 months ago #152749 by julz
Great topic

I actually chatted to some friends the other day and with their help I realised that we need to ideally look for a school that is best for our childs needs and which is fairly convenient for us as parents.

I would look at:

Schools near to me (primary school)
Size of class
Facilties they offer
cost


There are still fabulous public schools and we will be looking at sending Dylan to one my reasons being:

Closer to home ( I don't want to have to drive long distances to get him to school and back and to see his friends over weekends)

I want him to attend a school were the children come from a similar financial situation. It is fine to send him to Bishops, but I do worry as to how he will be treated when mom drops him off in her Tazz. I realise that he should understand that we all come from different backgrounds, but I attended a school where the parents had money (not us) and it seemed as if their kids always were the cream of the crop.

Facilities. I would like Dylan to attend a school that has good sporting and cultural facilities. I find that many of the newer private schools which are affordable do not offer much in the way of these facilities.



At this stage we are now looking at sending Dylan to an all boys school at high school level and will send him to one of our excellent primary schools near us.

Mom of Dylan and Partner to Joerg. We live in the Beautiful Pringle Bay which is along the Whale coast, Cape.


File Attachment:
File Attachment:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Powered by Kunena Forum
Don't have an account yet? Register Now!

Sign in to your account