My friend who had a emergency c/s last Jan was reminded at the time that had it been 100yrs back, and they hadnt done anything, both mom & baby would've died. Baby wasnt engaging but waters had broken and it was a long process before they decided on a c/s. It gave me a new appreciation for gynae's, who are saving lives a fair amount of the time when we take it for granted because we are so set on our plans. She'd wanted all natural with water birth, but in the end she got what saved her & her baby's life.
I have no experience of either, but the way I see it at this moment in time (more or less 4-6 weeks before my due date), the miracle of making , carrying and birthing a baby be it vaginally or through abdominal surgery is such a big thing that the method of delivery so to speak is of least relevance to me. Just to have a healthy child in my arms at the end of all of this I will be blessed.
We have to make informed decisions and be happy with our choice of doctor / midwife We can prepare by means of hypnobirthing, or getting abdominal bands. In the end it's up to us to be with a doctor that we know has our best interests in mind and accept that they have trained for births of whatever kind for years and years.
It's good to be aware that things do happen in both scenarios that could cause their own health problems afterwards which is really unfortunate and sad, which no one can relate to but those mom's whove been through it and therefore probably more passionate about facts and figures and we have to respect them for it.
But we cannot live in fear of our choices nor have to defend them. If one or the other was adversely worse, the medical industry would've put a stop to methods already.
I just want to appreciate the gift of life