I loved my NVD with no drugs. I had myself, my hubby, doula and midwife in the room and wasnt subjected to any invasive proceedures. I dont have a scar, and after I had delivered the placenta I got up and went for a shower on my own. I did tear a bit, so I was tender down below for a bit, but this was not excrutiating, and nothing that a few painkillers couldnt fix. I also took a stool softener afterwards to make it easy to go to the loo (when you feel bruised down below its easy to hold it in and become constipated)
There is no way I would choose to have a section, its an option only when medically neccesary (BTW my doc had told me that I needed to have a c -sec because my baby was too big, but I chose to challenge him and birthed a 3.9kg baby after an 8 hour labour with no complications. My tummy was gone within 2 weeks, but unfortunately I did put on a bit more weight than I should have so am still sitting with about 4kgs to shed before I'm back at prepreg weight.
I would never choose an operation when it wasnt needed - personally I think you need to be something of a masochist to choose someone to cut you open, no matter how much more convenient it is:)