Hi TCS,
Sjoo, what a curve-ball.
I'm pro c-section, you know that. BUT I also have respect for ladies who want a normal delivery. The same way that I respect both moms who breastfeed and bottle feed, nobody can say for sure their way is the right way.
I think your doctor is being a bully. You feel very strongly about a natural delivery, I think you should go for it. I agree that he has a point about taking the epidural, I never understood why women would want to go through all that agony and he does make a good point about the baby's monitoring. From what I understand the epi is not given early in the labour process, so you will still be able to experience everything until the last possible moment. The recovery from the pain control (epi/spinal block) is not the bad part, you have full sensation back in your body by no later than 6 hours and at worst you may experience some nausea for a day or so. Take the pain meds, for goodness sake. You have nothing to prove and it's not harmful to your baby. 24 hours of recovery after pain meds is NOTHING in comparison to the potential mental trauma you can cause yourself. Don't start your baby's life by being scarred by his birth, it's not fair on either of you.
Why could you not do a natural delivery but agree to a c-section if the baby becomes distressed or if if becomes medically necessary? Birth is a tricky business, both sides have their risks. A c-section is always easier for the doctor, because it's easy for them to plan their diaries and manage their own risks. Was your doctor equally explicit about risks of a c-section? I think he's being a bit manipulative by using your past to scare you. There's no physical evidence to show that you will have a complicated birth, for all we know your birth canal is like a water slide and the baby just glides out!
I started by saying that I'm pro c-section and just wanted to add that I had a really good experience and that's why I'm doing it the same way again. It's a major abdominal surgery, but they don't cut your muscles or whatever the people believed in the olden days. The pain after the procedure is managed by good pain medication and the intensity varies from woman to woman. I found the first 4 days quite difficult because your movement is impaired at first, but you're able to get up by the day after delivery and the sooner you move around the better you feel and the quicker the total recovery.
By one week after delivery the wound has healed on the outside but your insides take about 8 weeks to heal completely. Infection on the inside does happen but is actually rare, don't worry about it. I took pain medication on certain days during the first 2 weeks after delivery, but only when needed and not every day. After 2 weeks I didn't need any medication. I didn't have pain sitting (like some natural delivery moms) and of course sex after delivery wasn't painful.
The "pain" after a c-section feels like a burning sort of feeling, almost like you burned your hand on a stove, it's not a stabbing or aching pain. You may find it difficult in the first 10 days to lie flat on your back and may be more comfortable to sleep in 'n fetal-position. You will be able to pick up your baby and breastfeed from the moment he's born, but you may find it difficult to hang clothes on the wash line (not a bad thing in my opinion!).
If you opt for a c-section you can also ask the doctor to wait until you go into labour before the c-section is done (and not 2 weeks before). A lot of moms want their babies to come when the baby is ready, consider this option too.
Also, if you decide on a natural delivery, be prepared that a c-section may be necessary in the end. It sounds to me like you understand both ways pretty well and are open minded enough about it.
Remember my motto: it's about the baby and not about the delivery!